Justin Guarini: Fallen American Idol?
Scoop Contributiors Greg Adkins, Marisa Wong, Jennifer Wren, Dorothy Cascerceri, Sean Daly, Caris Davis, Rachel Felder, Dimi Gaidatzi, Deborah Geering, Monique Jessen, Oliver Jones, Marisa Laudadio, Linda Marx, Kwala Mandel, Dana Meltzer, Pete Norman, Vicki Sheff-Cahan, Cythia Wang
People, December 22, 2003 

Justin Guarini seemed poised for stardom after winning second place in last year's American Idol. But he was nowhere to be seen on FOX's American Idol holiday special that aired last month. What's more, he says, neither his record company nor his management will return his phone calls. What happened?

Guarini, who made an appearance in a shopping mall outside Atlanta to sign autographs recently, says contract negotiations kept him from the TV special. "We couldn't come to terms before the show," he says, "so I went on a vacation to New Zealand." Guarini's recording career is heading south as well; his self-titled debut CD sold only 135,000 copies. (By comparison, Idol winner Kelly Clarkson's album, Thankful, moved 1.7 million units; Clay Aiken, this year's Idol runner-up, sold 1.4 million copies of Measure of a Man.) RCA won't comment on reports they will let Guarini's contract expire.

But Guarini, 25, isn't ready to give up the biz. He's in L.A. meeting with executives at The WB about acting gigs (while staying at the home of The Simple Life's Nicole Richie, a friend from his pre-Idol days). And he's hoping to cut a second album. "He's a very talented guy," says Clarkson. "I have no doubt he'll be back in the public eye soon." Guarini has no regrets. "I'm not a believer of doing things over. If we could go back and fix all our mistakes, we'd never learn anything."

essentialjustin.com